Best by Company.

ACUITY Auto Insurance Company Profile
Read ratings and reviews. Get free quotes.

The ACUITY insurance company had its start in 1925 under the moniker "Mutual Auto Insurance Company." ACUITY adopted its current name in 2001 and was previously known as the Mutual Auto of Wisconsin in the 1950's and Heritage Mutual Insurance until the most recent name change. While sometimes this confuses consumers as they are unaware that ACUITY has been serving the public for so long, it does not hinder their business model in anyway. Their focus on customer service, quick claim payout, and hiring experts for their workforce is what makes them one of the leaders in the small insurance field. They offer great discounts to farmers and large families, so be sure to take advantage of them when discussing a new policy with an insurance agent. Much company pride is derived from the fact that it has never been purchased as a subsidiary arm of a larger corporation. Its large growth since its inception led to expansion and currently ACUITY operates in 19 states, and has over 850 employees. In addition ACUITY processes over 750 million dollars in gross premiums per year.

Quick Facts for ACUITY Car Insurance

  • Founded : 1925
  • HQ : Sheboygan, Wisconsin, USA
  • Auto Insurance : YES
  • Health Insurance : YES
  • Life Insurance : NO
  • Fortune 500 : NO
  • **S&P Best Financial Strength : A+
  • **S&P Best Credit Strength : A+
  • *A&M Best Rating : A+
  • ***J.D. Power Pricing Rating : N/R
  • J.D. Power Billing and Payment Rating : N/R
  • J.D. Power Policy Offerings Rating : N/R
  • J.D. Power Contacting Insurer Rating : N/R
  • J.D. Power Overall Satisfaction Rating : N/R
  • Customers Completely Satisfied % : 65%